There’s nothing particularly wrong with The Mandalorian and Grogu.
And that may be its biggest problem.
Seven years after Star Wars last occupied the big screen, Lucasfilm brings one of its most popular Disney+ creations to theaters with a movie that is colorful, fast-moving, occasionally exciting and perfectly fine for a rainy afternoon.
But a movie?
That’s where things get complicated.
Directed by Jon Favreau, who co-wrote the screenplay with Dave Filoni and Noah Kloor, The Mandalorian and Grogu feels less like the next great chapter in the Star Wars saga and more like several episodes of The Mandalorian stitched together, polished up and projected onto a much larger screen.
There’s a mission. Then another mission. A gladiator fight. A monster attack. A prison break. A bounty hunter. Another monster. Another escape. Another firefight.
And then it’s over.
The problem isn’t a lack of incident.
The movie is practically all incident.
What’s missing is discovery.
After spending three seasons with Din Djarin (Pedro Pascal) and Grogu, there is still an enormous amount we don’t know about either character. That should have been the opportunity here.
What does Din actually want beyond the next assignment? What does fatherhood mean to a man raised inside a rigid warrior culture? How has Grogu’s traumatic past shaped the person he is becoming? What is happening inside that tiny green head as his abilities grow? What does this strange little family mean to each of them?
There are potentially fascinating stories buried inside this relationship.
The movie barely touches them.
Instead, Din and Grogu are sent on another job.
Following the fall of the Galactic Empire, Din is working with the New Republic hunting Imperial holdouts when he is recruited to rescue Rotta the Hutt, Jabba’s son and heir. In exchange, the New Republic hopes to obtain information about a mysterious warlord.
REELated:
From Sorting Hats to Quidditch, HBO releases Harry Potter trailer
Naturally, nothing goes according to plan.
Rotta, voiced by Jeremy Allen White, has reinvented himself as a Hulk-like gladiator and has little interest in being rescued. His situation eventually pulls Din and Grogu into a larger conflict involving crime bosses, bounty hunters, Hutts and enough creatures to keep Industrial Light & Magic busy for months.
Basically, Mandalorian: Ragnarok
There’s certainly fun to be had along the way.
Favreau knows how to stage Star Wars action, and the film opens strongly with Din infiltrating a snowy Imperial installation and battling his way through a sequence that immediately reminds us why this character became so popular in the first place.
He looks cool.
He moves cool.
He shoots things very cool.
Pascal remains a compelling presence even when most of his performance is coming from beneath a helmet, aided physically by Brendan Wayne and Lateef Crowder.
And Grogu remains Grogu.
He’s adorable. He eats things. He uses the Force. He gets himself into trouble. He gets Din out of trouble.
The formula still works.
It just isn’t evolving.
And that may be because Favreau plays the whole thing remarkably safe.
He knows exactly what audiences like about The Mandalorian: Din looking cool, Grogu being adorable, strange creatures, recognizable Star Wars iconography, tightly staged action and just enough sentiment to keep the relationship at the center.
So he gives us all of it.
Again.
What he rarely does is risk changing the equation.
Din is never pushed far enough emotionally to reveal something genuinely new about himself. Grogu’s powers are expanded when the action requires it, but his inner life remains largely untouched. Even the movie’s biggest dangers are structured to return the characters to familiar ground rather than force them somewhere uncomfortable.
That safety makes the film easy to watch.
It also makes it easy to forget. But perfect for a rainy day watch.
A theatrical movie should have been the moment to disrupt the rhythm of the series – to challenge Din and Grogu, separate them emotionally, expose something we haven’t seen or fundamentally alter their relationship.
Favreau instead treats the movie almost like a victory lap for a formula that already worked on television.
Even Din’s near-death experience – which should provide an opportunity to deepen his bond with Grogu — becomes another obstacle to overcome before the movie races toward its next action sequence.
That’s what ultimately makes the film feel strangely inconsequential.
The stakes are technically high.
The emotional stakes rarely are.
Sigourney Weaver brings welcome authority as New Republic commander Ward, and the supporting cast, including Jeremy Allen White, Jonny Coyne and others, adds some new flavor to the galaxy.
But even the new characters tend to function more as pieces moving Din toward his next destination than people who significantly alter him.
And that’s the frustration.
There is an interesting movie sitting just beneath this one. A movie about a warrior learning how to become a father. A movie about a child carrying enormous trauma and extraordinary power.
A movie about two damaged beings who found each other and created something resembling a family in the middle of a galaxy still recovering from war.
Instead, we get a mission to rescue a Hutt.
To be fair, The Mandalorian and Grogu looks and sounds like Star Wars. Ludwig Göransson’s score remains one of the strongest elements of this corner of the franchise, and there are enough creatures, practical effects, spaceships and familiar visual flourishes to deliver that comforting galaxy-far-far-away feeling.
There are also moments where seeing this world on a giant screen works exactly as intended.
But spectacle isn’t the same thing as scale.
A story can feature enormous monsters and still feel small.
That’s ultimately where The Mandalorian and Grogu lands.
It’s not terrible.
It’s not even particularly disappointing while you’re watching it.
It moves quickly enough. Grogu is still lovable. Din is still cool. Things explode.
You’ll probably have a decent time.
But when the credits roll, it’s difficult to identify anything we now understand about these characters that we didn’t understand two hours earlier.
For the first Star Wars theatrical release in seven years, that feels like a missed opportunity.
The Mandalorian and Grogu doesn’t feel like the beginning of an exciting new cinematic chapter.
It feels like Season Four with the commercial breaks removed. And on a rainy day, that’s fine.
For Star Wars returning to the big screen?
We should have learned something more.
BOTTOM LINE: The Mandalorian and Grogu mostly gives us bigger, safer versions of things the series has already done. It’s safe as a REEL STREAM.
The Geek is a working screenwriter, director and screenwriting instructor.
