Marvel Studios may finally have the fresh start it and Spider-Man have been looking for. Following its Los Angeles premiere, Spider-Man: Brand New Day has arrived to strong critical acclaim, debuting with a 91% Fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes while generating one of the most enthusiastic receptions for a Marvel Studios release since Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3.
The fourth solo outing for Tom Holland’s Peter Parker marks a dramatic tonal shift from the multiverse spectacle of Spider-Man: No Way Home. Set four years after Doctor Strange’s memory spell erased Peter Parker from the lives of everyone he loved, Brand New Day follows an older, isolated Peter who has embraced life as New York City’s anonymous protector. When his powers begin changing in unexpected ways and a mysterious new threat emerges, Spider-Man finds himself confronting dangers that are as psychological as they are physical.
Directed by Destin Daniel Cretton (Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings), the film reunites Holland with Zendaya and Jacob Batalon while adding Jon Bernthal, Sadie Sink, Mark Ruffalo, Michael Mando and Tramell Tillman to the expanding Spider-Man universe.
Tom Holland’s Spider-Man finally grows up
If there’s one point critics overwhelmingly agree on, it’s that this is Holland’s finest performance in the role.
Third Coast Review’s Steven Prokopy calls Brand New Day “a more mature, grounded, focused, emotionally driven, and broken-hearted version of Peter than we’ve ever seen.”
Looper’s Reuben Baron goes even further, ranking it among Marvel’s strongest post-Endgame efforts. “It’s on par with Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 in the top tier of post-Avengers: Endgame Marvel movies, and it’s my favorite live-action Spider-Man movie since Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man 2.”
That comparison appears repeatedly throughout the early reviews. Rather than chasing another multiverse event, critics say Brand New Day succeeds by bringing Spider-Man back to street level and focusing on Peter Parker himself.
Den of Geek’s David Crow praised the emotional balance Holland achieves: “At last Holland is liberated to play the joy, as well as the agony and sorrow. It’s this triptych that makes Peter’s crucible of growing up so relatable.”
Similarly, Amelia Emberwing of Pickety Witch called it “both the best of Holland’s Spider-Man films and the best thing to come out with Marvel’s name attached to it for some time.”
Destin Daniel Cretton gives Spider-Man a new visual identity
Another consistent theme throughout the reviews is praise for Cretton’s filmmaking. After Jon Watts directed Holland’s first trilogy, many critics believe Cretton injects a fresh visual energy into the franchise.
Eric Goldman praised the balance between spectacle and introspection. “It’s a more introspective story, but it’s also the best-looking of the Tom Holland Spider-Man movies so far, with some really creative action.”
Brian Orndorf of Blu-ray.com credited Cretton with successfully launching Spider-Man into a new phase. “Cretton nails the most important parts of the offering, and he manages to get everything upright again as Spider-Man figures out the next phase of his heroism.”
Several critics specifically highlighted the action choreography, practical camerawork and darker visual tone, suggesting this is Marvel’s strongest-directed Spider-Man film since Sam Raimi’s original trilogy.
REELated:
Marvel announces new Black Panther and release date
Jon Bernthal and Sadie Sink steal the spotlight
Beyond Holland, two names surface repeatedly.
Jon Bernthal’s Punisher is earning praise for bringing genuine dramatic tension to the MCU, with reviewers pointing to his ideological clashes with Spider-Man as some of the movie’s strongest scenes.
Meanwhile, Sadie Sink, whose role has remained one of Marvel’s best-kept secrets, is being described as one of the film’s breakout performers.
Without venturing into spoiler territory, multiple critics suggest Sink’s character plays a far more significant role than audiences might expect and could reshape Spider-Man’s future.
A return to Spider-Man’s street-level roots
Many reviewers see Brand New Day as a welcome course correction after Marvel’s increasingly cosmic storytelling.
Danielle Solzman of Solzy at the Movies writes: “Spider-Man: Brand New Day successfully launches a new era for the web-slinger by returning Peter Parker to his street-level roots while still delivering the heart, humor and action audiences have come to expect.”
Alexander Zalben of Comic Book Club echoed that sentiment, calling the movie: “A brand new day for Tom Holland’s Spider-Man franchise… a deftly constructed juggling act that never loses sight of the Spider-Man in the middle.”
Joey Morona of the Cleveland Plain Dealer believes the film accomplishes something perhaps even more important than trying to top No Way Home. “Brand New Day might not reach the dizzying highs of No Way Home, but it’s arguably the more complete movie—and the reset the franchise needs.”
Not everyone is convinced
Still, the reviews aren’t universally glowing. Several critics argue Marvel continues struggling with one of its biggest post-Endgame problems: setting up tomorrow’s movies at the expense of today’s.
RogerEbert.com’s Brian Tallerico writes: “Affection for the characters… goes a long way to holding Brand New Day together, but it ultimately succumbs to one of the biggest problems of late-stage MCU: the feeling that it’s just preparation for more movies.”
Kevin Maher of The Times admired the emotional core but questioned whether the film ever fully escapes superhero convention. “Despite the film’s undeniable emotional power, there is evident frustration about where this drama might have gone if freed from the limitations of overfamiliar box-ticking biff-bammery.”
Odie Henderson of the Boston Globe expressed a similar criticism, arguing too much of the runtime is devoted to introducing characters and future storylines instead of focusing exclusively on Peter Parker.
One of the harsher reviews came from Film Authority’s Eddie Harrison, who gave the film 2 out of 5 stars, writing: “…the MCU malaise seems to have spread to the Spider-Verse… the various narrative dead-ends gum up the works of this rather dank and tiresome comic-book epic.”
The early consensus
Despite those criticisms, the overall picture remains overwhelmingly positive.
Review after review returns to the same themes:
- Tom Holland delivers perhaps his richest performance as Peter Parker.
- Destin Daniel Cretton reinvigorates the franchise with confident direction.
- Jon Bernthal and Sadie Sink emerge as standout additions.
- The emotional storytelling feels more intimate than recent MCU entries.
- The third act occasionally buckles under the weight of Marvel’s expanding universe.
Perhaps Matt Oakes of Silver Screen Riot summed it up best: “Although the bar has been impractically low since Avengers: Endgame, the Spider-Man brand remains the MCU’s sturdiest tentpole, and Spider-Man: Brand New Day is the best thing the studio has delivered since, well, the last Spider-Man sequel.”
After years of criticism that Marvel had become too reliant on multiverses, cameos and franchise setup, Spider-Man: Brand New Day appears to remind audiences, and critics, that the studio’s greatest superpower has always been compelling characters.
For now, at least, critics seem to agree that Peter Parker has finally found his footing again. Watch the trailer below:
The Geek is a working screenwriter, director and screenwriting instructor.
