‘Jimmy’ reveals the war behind Jimmy Stewart’s wonderful life

Jimmy
Courtesy of Burns and Company)

Every Christmas, my family has the same argument about which movie we’re going to watch. One daughter insists on A Christmas Story, the one with Ralphie and his Red Ryder BB gun. My ex-husband makes his annual case for Die Hard, which, for the record, he considers to be a Christmas movie. My youngest daughter votes for Elf. And I always choose It’s a Wonderful Life.

I’ve never really considered why I’m so attached to that particular film. Perhaps it’s because I’ve always gravitated toward movies that explore the more complicated aspects of human nature, and beneath its surface as a heartwarming Christmas classic, It’s a Wonderful Life is an extraordinarily dark and emotionally complex story about despair, sacrifice, disappointment and the often-unrecognized impact we have on other people’s lives.

Jimmy Stewart’s portrayal of George Bailey is arguably one of the finest performances of his career. My favorite scene is the one in which a desperate Bailey sits alone at Martini’s bar and prays to God for help. What I never knew, until watching Aaron Burns’ new biographical drama Jimmy, was just how much Stewart himself had endured before making that film, and how profoundly his experiences during World War II informed the performance and that particular scene that I’ve admired for so many years.

KJ Apa (Riverdale) portrays Stewart at the height of his Hollywood career, shortly after winning an Academy Award for The Philadelphia Story in 1941. Rather than seek a military deferment, as MGM preferred, Stewart enlisted in the Army Air Corps, eventually flying bomber missions over Germany and commanding men whose lives depended on his leadership. The film explores the psychological consequences of war and the extraordinary contrast between the glamour of Hollywood and the brutality of combat.

Apa is remarkable, capturing Stewart’s distinctive voice, mannerisms and understated charm without allowing the performance to become an impersonation. More impressive is his portrayal of a man increasingly consumed by guilt and responsibility. The seemingly effortless confidence of a Hollywood star gradually gives way to a vulnerability that is both unsettling and deeply affecting.

In one of the film’s most powerful scenes, Stewart confesses to Lady Julia (Kara Killmer) that he feels like a fraud. He recognizes that he has been using the very skills that made him a successful actor to inspire frightened young men to climb aboard bombers, knowing some will never return. What makes this scene so impactful is the moral dilemma. Stewart genuinely believes in the importance of their mission, yet he cannot reconcile that conviction with the deaths of men he has persuaded to follow him.

Killmer is particularly effective opposite Apa, allowing the emotional weight of his confession to unfold without unnecessary melodrama. The supporting ensemble, including Max Casella as Frank Capra, Jason Alexander as MGM studio head Louis B. Mayer, Rob Riggle as Colonel Terril, Neal McDonough as Stewart’s father, Christopher McDonald as actor Lionel Barrymore and Sarah Drew as gossip columnist Hedda Hopper, further grounds a film that could easily have become an overly sentimental Hollywood biography.

But perhaps the most extraordinary moment involves something as seemingly insignificant as a handkerchief.

Before leaving Hollywood, Stewart collects lipstick kisses from glamorous actresses, including Rita Hayworth and Ginger Rogers. It’s a charming souvenir of his celebrity, a reminder of the world he has left behind. But when Lieutenant Martinez (Julian Works) dies following a mission, Stewart takes out that same handkerchief and gently wipes the young man’s blood from his face.

I found this scene devastating. So much so that I was reduced to tears in the AMC theater.

Those lipstick kisses, once symbols of Hollywood glamour and celebrity, suddenly seemed absurdly superficial compared with the blood of a young man who has sacrificed his life. In one simple gesture, Burns communicates the difference between being celebrated and making a contribution that truly matters.

“You risk your lives so that others won’t have to.”

Stewart tells his men as he rallies them for what amounts to a suicide mission, delivering one of the most powerful speeches I’ve ever heard in a film.

It made me think about how easily we celebrate fame while overlooking genuine sacrifice. The people whose courage and service shape our lives rarely receive the attention we give to celebrities.

Ironically, Stewart himself addresses this very idea in It’s a Wonderful Life, when George Bailey confronts Mr. Potter and defends the people who do most of the working, paying, living and dying in Bedford Falls. After watching Jimmy, that speech takes on an entirely different significance.

What makes Jimmy so compelling is that it doesn’t simply celebrate Stewart as a war hero or Hollywood legend. It reveals the complicated psychology of a man who believed deeply in duty, sacrifice and responsibility, yet struggled with the terrible consequences of those convictions.

Perhaps that’s what I find most moving about this film. We live in a society that places extraordinary value on recognition, wealth and personal success. Yet Stewart’s life reminds us that character is often revealed by what we’re willing to give up, rather than what we’re able to acquire.

This Christmas, when my family inevitably starts arguing about which movie to watch, I’ll still choose It’s a Wonderful Life. But I suspect I’ll be watching George Bailey with an entirely different understanding of the man who brought him to life. Watch the trailer below:

BOTTOM LINE: KJ Apa delivers an exceptional, emotionally nuanced performance in Jimmy, a powerful examination of the psychological toll of war, the burden of leadership and the difference between celebrity and genuine character, making this movie a REEL SEE.

Amy Pais-Richer is a published author, screenwriter, and former advertising creative director.


Jimmy
Courtesy of Burns and Company)

Every Christmas, my family has the same argument about which movie we’re going to watch. One daughter insists on A Christmas Story, the one with Ralphie and his Red Ryder BB gun. My ex-husband makes his annual case for Die Hard, which, for the record, he considers to be a Christmas movie. My youngest daughter votes for Elf. And I always choose It’s a Wonderful Life.

I’ve never really considered why I’m so attached to that particular film. Perhaps it’s because I’ve always gravitated toward movies that explore the more complicated aspects of human nature, and beneath its surface as a heartwarming Christmas classic, It’s a Wonderful Life is an extraordinarily dark and emotionally complex story about despair, sacrifice, disappointment and the often-unrecognized impact we have on other people’s lives.

Jimmy Stewart’s portrayal of George Bailey is arguably one of the finest performances of his career. My favorite scene is the one in which a desperate Bailey sits alone at Martini’s bar and prays to God for help. What I never knew, until watching Aaron Burns’ new biographical drama Jimmy, was just how much Stewart himself had endured before making that film, and how profoundly his experiences during World War II informed the performance and that particular scene that I’ve admired for so many years.

KJ Apa (Riverdale) portrays Stewart at the height of his Hollywood career, shortly after winning an Academy Award for The Philadelphia Story in 1941. Rather than seek a military deferment, as MGM preferred, Stewart enlisted in the Army Air Corps, eventually flying bomber missions over Germany and commanding men whose lives depended on his leadership. The film explores the psychological consequences of war and the extraordinary contrast between the glamour of Hollywood and the brutality of combat.

Apa is remarkable, capturing Stewart’s distinctive voice, mannerisms and understated charm without allowing the performance to become an impersonation. More impressive is his portrayal of a man increasingly consumed by guilt and responsibility. The seemingly effortless confidence of a Hollywood star gradually gives way to a vulnerability that is both unsettling and deeply affecting.

In one of the film’s most powerful scenes, Stewart confesses to Lady Julia (Kara Killmer) that he feels like a fraud. He recognizes that he has been using the very skills that made him a successful actor to inspire frightened young men to climb aboard bombers, knowing some will never return. What makes this scene so impactful is the moral dilemma. Stewart genuinely believes in the importance of their mission, yet he cannot reconcile that conviction with the deaths of men he has persuaded to follow him.

Killmer is particularly effective opposite Apa, allowing the emotional weight of his confession to unfold without unnecessary melodrama. The supporting ensemble, including Max Casella as Frank Capra, Jason Alexander as MGM studio head Louis B. Mayer, Rob Riggle as Colonel Terril, Neal McDonough as Stewart’s father, Christopher McDonald as actor Lionel Barrymore and Sarah Drew as gossip columnist Hedda Hopper, further grounds a film that could easily have become an overly sentimental Hollywood biography.

But perhaps the most extraordinary moment involves something as seemingly insignificant as a handkerchief.

Before leaving Hollywood, Stewart collects lipstick kisses from glamorous actresses, including Rita Hayworth and Ginger Rogers. It’s a charming souvenir of his celebrity, a reminder of the world he has left behind. But when Lieutenant Martinez (Julian Works) dies following a mission, Stewart takes out that same handkerchief and gently wipes the young man’s blood from his face.

I found this scene devastating. So much so that I was reduced to tears in the AMC theater.

Those lipstick kisses, once symbols of Hollywood glamour and celebrity, suddenly seemed absurdly superficial compared with the blood of a young man who has sacrificed his life. In one simple gesture, Burns communicates the difference between being celebrated and making a contribution that truly matters.

“You risk your lives so that others won’t have to.”

Stewart tells his men as he rallies them for what amounts to a suicide mission, delivering one of the most powerful speeches I’ve ever heard in a film.

It made me think about how easily we celebrate fame while overlooking genuine sacrifice. The people whose courage and service shape our lives rarely receive the attention we give to celebrities.

Ironically, Stewart himself addresses this very idea in It’s a Wonderful Life, when George Bailey confronts Mr. Potter and defends the people who do most of the working, paying, living and dying in Bedford Falls. After watching Jimmy, that speech takes on an entirely different significance.

What makes Jimmy so compelling is that it doesn’t simply celebrate Stewart as a war hero or Hollywood legend. It reveals the complicated psychology of a man who believed deeply in duty, sacrifice and responsibility, yet struggled with the terrible consequences of those convictions.

Perhaps that’s what I find most moving about this film. We live in a society that places extraordinary value on recognition, wealth and personal success. Yet Stewart’s life reminds us that character is often revealed by what we’re willing to give up, rather than what we’re able to acquire.

This Christmas, when my family inevitably starts arguing about which movie to watch, I’ll still choose It’s a Wonderful Life. But I suspect I’ll be watching George Bailey with an entirely different understanding of the man who brought him to life. Watch the trailer below:

BOTTOM LINE: KJ Apa delivers an exceptional, emotionally nuanced performance in Jimmy, a powerful examination of the psychological toll of war, the burden of leadership and the difference between celebrity and genuine character, making this movie a REEL SEE.

Amy Pais-Richer is a published author, screenwriter, and former advertising creative director.