I Loved ‘Digger.’ So why did so few people show up?

Digger
(Courtesy of Warner Bros.)

I loved Digger. I loved that Alejandro González Iñárritu went digging for bold choices and, when he found them, actually made them. And I loved that Tom Cruise really tried. You can feel him putting his considerable movie-star authority behind a character whose conviction that he’s the only man who can save the world is precisely what makes him so dangerous.

Cruise plays Digger Rockwell, an aging Texas oil tycoon who sets an environmental catastrophe in motion and then sets out to prove he’s humanity’s savior. Under the prosthetics, the gray hair, and the Texas drawl, he’s an actor using one of the things he does best. Cruise knows how to make you believe a man can walk into a room and take charge. Here, the longer you believe him, the funnier and more alarming it gets.

Riz Ahmed gives all that bluster something to push against. As Ganesh, the scientist who has to contend with Digger, Ahmed keeps his performance measured enough that you can feel the stakes even when Cruise is making you laugh. John Goodman, meanwhile, goes big as the president, with Michael Stuhlbarg playing his vice president. There’s a nasty joke in watching a roomful of powerful men try to sound in control when the guy who helped cause the catastrophe is pitching himself as the solution.

Sandra Hüller plays Emma, Digger’s half-sister and business partner, with the particular exhaustion of someone who’s heard her brother’s sales pitch a thousand times and still has to sit through it. Jesse Plemons works even quieter as Kenny. In a movie full of men fighting to be heard, Plemons makes you lean in. There’s a reason I’m leaving his role at that. Part of the pleasure of Digger is watching Iñárritu change the terms of the movie you thought you were watching, and Plemons is central to how he pulls it off.

I felt a kinship with Iñárritu’s Birdman and Bardo in the way reality bends around a man with a grand idea of himself. And I love The Revenant, which has a very different kind of force. What I respond to in all four films is Iñárritu’s willingness to push an idea far enough that some viewers will simply refuse to go with him. With Digger, he and cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki shot the whole thing in VistaVision. There’s something gloriously excessive about giving an oilman’s ego that much screen to fill.


50 years later, ‘Rocky’ still has our hearts


What did audiences actually reject?

At the box office, the answer is pretty clear. Digger opened to $8 million domestically across 3,321 theaters, fell 60 percent in its second weekend, and has grossed about $50.4 million worldwide against a reported $125 million production budget. It had a wide release and one of the world’s most recognizable stars. Very few people made buying a ticket a priority.

What people thought once they got there is more complicated. Opening-night moviegoers gave it a C+ CinemaScore, while Rotten Tomatoes lists 52 percent from critics and 77 percent from verified audience ratings. Those measures come from different groups. The first captures opening-night reactions, while the second comes from viewers who chose to rate the film. Together, they leave room for a movie that disappointed plenty of people right out of the gate and still found viewers who were glad they went. I’m one of them.

Warner Bros. even tried folding the bad reviews into the advertising, inviting people to decide for themselves. I get the impulse. I’m less sure it gave anyone a reason to call a friend and say, “We need to see this Friday.” A trailer has a hard enough job selling an absurdist climate satire. Adding a debate about whether the movie works gives people one more reason to wait.

‘Give us something original’ is only half the ask

I think audiences mean it when they say they want something original. I also think most of us, staring at showtimes on a Friday night, want some idea of what kind of evening we’re buying. Sinners could give you that in a sentence. Ryan Coogler made an original vampire movie that could sell the pleasures of a vampire movie while keeping much of what made it singular a surprise.

It grossed roughly $371 million worldwide. Iñárritu’s own The Revenant had a survival story you could grasp immediately and made more than $500 million worldwide. Both asked audiences to go somewhere unfamiliar. Both gave them a clear reason to walk through the door.

Digger is harder to recommend in a sentence, even for somebody who loved it. “Come see Tom Cruise play a man who might end the world while trying to take credit for saving it” works on me. I can also imagine a friend hearing that pitch and asking what else is playing. And at a reported $125 million, the movie needed a lot of those friends to say yes.

LONDON, ENGLAND – SEPTEMBER 22: Tom Cruise and Alejandro González Iñárritu attend the “Digger” World Premiere & Royal Film Performance™on September 22, 2026 in London, England. (Photo by John Phillips/Getty Images for Warner Bros. )

That’s what I keep coming back to. I want another movie where Cruise risks looking ridiculous. I want Iñárritu to follow an idea past the point where somebody in a meeting would reasonably ask him to pull back. And I want studios to get better at making the invitation. Tell me what’s funny, unnerving or worth arguing about on the drive home. Then trust me to decide whether I’m up for it.

I was up for Digger. I’m still thinking about it. For a movie that was easy to skip and hard to shake, that’s a big part of what I loved.

The Geek is a working screenwriter, director and screenwriting instructor.


Digger
(Courtesy of Warner Bros.)

I loved Digger. I loved that Alejandro González Iñárritu went digging for bold choices and, when he found them, actually made them. And I loved that Tom Cruise really tried. You can feel him putting his considerable movie-star authority behind a character whose conviction that he’s the only man who can save the world is precisely what makes him so dangerous.

Cruise plays Digger Rockwell, an aging Texas oil tycoon who sets an environmental catastrophe in motion and then sets out to prove he’s humanity’s savior. Under the prosthetics, the gray hair, and the Texas drawl, he’s an actor using one of the things he does best. Cruise knows how to make you believe a man can walk into a room and take charge. Here, the longer you believe him, the funnier and more alarming it gets.

Riz Ahmed gives all that bluster something to push against. As Ganesh, the scientist who has to contend with Digger, Ahmed keeps his performance measured enough that you can feel the stakes even when Cruise is making you laugh. John Goodman, meanwhile, goes big as the president, with Michael Stuhlbarg playing his vice president. There’s a nasty joke in watching a roomful of powerful men try to sound in control when the guy who helped cause the catastrophe is pitching himself as the solution.

Sandra Hüller plays Emma, Digger’s half-sister and business partner, with the particular exhaustion of someone who’s heard her brother’s sales pitch a thousand times and still has to sit through it. Jesse Plemons works even quieter as Kenny. In a movie full of men fighting to be heard, Plemons makes you lean in. There’s a reason I’m leaving his role at that. Part of the pleasure of Digger is watching Iñárritu change the terms of the movie you thought you were watching, and Plemons is central to how he pulls it off.

I felt a kinship with Iñárritu’s Birdman and Bardo in the way reality bends around a man with a grand idea of himself. And I love The Revenant, which has a very different kind of force. What I respond to in all four films is Iñárritu’s willingness to push an idea far enough that some viewers will simply refuse to go with him. With Digger, he and cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki shot the whole thing in VistaVision. There’s something gloriously excessive about giving an oilman’s ego that much screen to fill.


50 years later, ‘Rocky’ still has our hearts


What did audiences actually reject?

At the box office, the answer is pretty clear. Digger opened to $8 million domestically across 3,321 theaters, fell 60 percent in its second weekend, and has grossed about $50.4 million worldwide against a reported $125 million production budget. It had a wide release and one of the world’s most recognizable stars. Very few people made buying a ticket a priority.

What people thought once they got there is more complicated. Opening-night moviegoers gave it a C+ CinemaScore, while Rotten Tomatoes lists 52 percent from critics and 77 percent from verified audience ratings. Those measures come from different groups. The first captures opening-night reactions, while the second comes from viewers who chose to rate the film. Together, they leave room for a movie that disappointed plenty of people right out of the gate and still found viewers who were glad they went. I’m one of them.

Warner Bros. even tried folding the bad reviews into the advertising, inviting people to decide for themselves. I get the impulse. I’m less sure it gave anyone a reason to call a friend and say, “We need to see this Friday.” A trailer has a hard enough job selling an absurdist climate satire. Adding a debate about whether the movie works gives people one more reason to wait.

‘Give us something original’ is only half the ask

I think audiences mean it when they say they want something original. I also think most of us, staring at showtimes on a Friday night, want some idea of what kind of evening we’re buying. Sinners could give you that in a sentence. Ryan Coogler made an original vampire movie that could sell the pleasures of a vampire movie while keeping much of what made it singular a surprise.

It grossed roughly $371 million worldwide. Iñárritu’s own The Revenant had a survival story you could grasp immediately and made more than $500 million worldwide. Both asked audiences to go somewhere unfamiliar. Both gave them a clear reason to walk through the door.

Digger is harder to recommend in a sentence, even for somebody who loved it. “Come see Tom Cruise play a man who might end the world while trying to take credit for saving it” works on me. I can also imagine a friend hearing that pitch and asking what else is playing. And at a reported $125 million, the movie needed a lot of those friends to say yes.

LONDON, ENGLAND – SEPTEMBER 22: Tom Cruise and Alejandro González Iñárritu attend the “Digger” World Premiere & Royal Film Performance™on September 22, 2026 in London, England. (Photo by John Phillips/Getty Images for Warner Bros. )

That’s what I keep coming back to. I want another movie where Cruise risks looking ridiculous. I want Iñárritu to follow an idea past the point where somebody in a meeting would reasonably ask him to pull back. And I want studios to get better at making the invitation. Tell me what’s funny, unnerving or worth arguing about on the drive home. Then trust me to decide whether I’m up for it.

I was up for Digger. I’m still thinking about it. For a movie that was easy to skip and hard to shake, that’s a big part of what I loved.

The Geek is a working screenwriter, director and screenwriting instructor.